Empath or Trauma Response?
Are you an empath, or are trauma responses being expressed from childhood? In recent years, a number of people who have identified themselves as empaths have expressed an attitude of superiority to those who are not empaths. They think they are “special.” I find this troubling on multiple levels. An empath is not something that you train or study to become; it is typically a response to childhood trauma and a heightened sense of vigilance.
Is experiencing a challenging childhood a reason to feel superior to others?
On the one hand, it gives us a window into the strength, courage, and resiliency of a person. On the other hand, it is a survival skill due to unstable or violent/abusive childhood experiences that were created to protect us from the world around us. This would be similar to feeling superior to someone because you have PTSD, and they don’t. Post Traumatic Stress Disorder is not something anyone wants or feels proud of. We may feel proud that we survived, but not the actual experiences themselves. Empaths are typically created out of PTSD.
Let’s explore the relationship between being an empath and trauma response(s) from childhood traumas together. I invite you to open your mind and allow the research to offer clues to how and what an empath is. We cannot let our ego get in the way of our path to healing.
What is “special” about a shitty childhood?
What is “Divine” or “Gifted” about not feeling loved or that you matter as a child?
Empath or Trauma Response?
“Is Your Empathetic Nature a Trauma Response?
Science is beginning to think it is.
What is Empathy?
The word “empathy” is defined by the dictionary as, “the ability to understand and share the feelings of another.” However, for those who would describe themselves as extremely empathetic or an “empath,” this definition falls short.
To be an empath means to feel everything around you. To sense the subtle shifts of the energy in a room or of a person. To feel overwhelmed in loud or chaotic environments. It means you have an ability to see beneath the layers of the persona a person presents — down to their core. To understand the pain that drives their behavior — and often have a yearning to then fix the pain — or at least look beyond it and love the person anyway.
Most people who are empaths will not realize for many years how differently they navigate the world from others. They will just believe they are “too sensitive” or “weird” because those who do not understand (or are threatened by) empathy, will convince them it is true.
Unfortunately, it will often take being taken advantage of by narcissistic people, or energy vampires, more than once before an empath will begin to understand what drives them to love so big and forgive so easily.
In fact, this is one of the many reasons emphathetic people are often drawn to narcissists and vice versa. Empaths are programmed to give, while narcissists are programmed to take and these two opposing personality dynamics are like magnets.
But now science is starting to understand just how much traumatic childhoods can impact the overall empathy of an adult.
The Study of Empathy as a Trauma Response
In a research study led by David M. Greenberg of the University of Cambridge, two groups of adults were surveyed using different empathy measures. In both groups, adults who reported experiencing traumatic events as children (including death, sexual abuse, parental divorce, and physical abuse) reported higher levels of affective empathy. Meaning they were better equipped to understand the mental state of others and respond appropriately.
Another study published in 2019 followed 84 children— half of which had been exposed to traumatic events from a very young age — to assess their empathy responses when they became preadolescents. The study found that those children who had experienced strained mother-child relationships showed a higher amount of both affective and cognitive empathy.
The study concluded that “caregiving patterns” had a direct impact on the shaping and development of empathy.
Why Childhood Trauma Leads to Higher Empathy
Children raised in chaotic, unstable households or with parents who are selfish and display erratic behavior, learn from a young age to sense what is going on around them. Children learn to sense the energy of a person or situation and react accordingly. It is a survival technique.
Children who are raised by narcissists are also taught that they are responsible for the happiness (or unhappiness) of those around them and learn to carry other people’s emotions on their backs. They hold themselves responsible and are in a constant state of high alert in an attempt to keep the peace and feel as safe as possible.
These children are also taught that love is transactional and are in the constant pursuit of people-pleasing in order to earn love.
This is why highly empathetic and intuitive adults often unknowingly end up with narcissistic people. They are simply reliving their childhood and gravitating towards what they were taught is love.
Unfortunately, it will take getting hurt by selfish people quite a bit before an empath will begin to understand their own trauma responses and start to undo the programming.
Is your empathetic nature a trauma response? Science is starting to slowly understand that it is. And while discovering you are an empath can feel like both a blessing and a curse — simply taking the time to understand why you navigate the world as you do and also become aware of the kind of people who will take advantage of your big heart and caring nature will help you get a better grasp on the world around you.”
This excerpt is from the article Is Your Empathetic Nature a Trauma Response? by Lena Ann on Medium.
Am I an Empath, a Trauma Survivor or Both?
“When you hear descriptive details about someone, like they are profoundly empathic, feel the energy in the room, have well-honed senses, notice subtleties, isolate to recharge, or tune into others mood shifts, do you think, “They’re an empath?”
Of course, they may be an empath, but did you know these identifying details also describe a trauma survivor?
I am an empath. I am a highly sensitive, keenly perceptive, empathetic person who has endured traumatic events in my past that molded the way I experienced the world.
As an empath, I’m not just hearing the conversation, but noticing the energy all around me. As a trauma survivor, my brain comfortably sat in a hypervigilant state, searching for anything similar to my past trauma, hoping to protect me from future danger.⠀
Following trauma, we can have physical, emotional, and psychological changes within our brains. The structure of our brain can change in three ways: some parts grow more prominent, some shrink, and other processes deteriorate.
Three sections of our brain highly affected by trauma are:
1. The amygdala plays a critical role in emotional regulation, detecting threats, and alerting us of danger. After trauma, this part of our brain can grow larger, but unfortunately, through its growth, it begins to overpower the other parts of our brain (hypervigilance. When our amygdala is enlarged, emotions rather than reason become how we manage our responses.
2. The pre-frontal cortex, which is in charge of cognitive processing, becomes smaller and less efficient in response to trauma. When weakened, we lose our ability to reason and process new information logically, and our capacity to recall and store memories is also impaired.
3. The hippocampus supports learning and long-term memory. When stress chemicals like cortisol, adrenaline, and norepinephrine routinely flood our bodies, they can damage the neural capacity of the hippocampus and the pre-frontal cortex.
Trauma and the empath.
Some empaths are afraid of their day-to-day life.
Believing they are powerless over what they feel and perceive, some can worry about what they will sense around others. A constant state of fear can lead to trauma and a hypervigilant state. Hypervigilance can make the empath feel like they are observant of unseen dangers, whether from people or their environment. However, many times, in a hypervigilant state, the threats we perceive are not real.
I realized I was an empath many years ago. For most of my life, my emotional world kept me in constant torment. Life felt difficult. The act of refining the extent of what I felt seemed an unrelenting task.
As I grew older and experienced the weight of personal trauma, it became impossible to distinguish my feelings from others. Finally, I started internalizing everything I experienced, and in hindsight, I see that I equated my overwhelm as proof I was fundamentally flawed.
Eventually, my encounters with trauma, which needed compassion and loving attention, were drowned by the unrelenting pain and suffering of the world around me.
To fully step into my potential, I had to sort out what was affecting my energy in each moment. As I identified and healed my trauma, I freed myself to feel stronger and more grounded around the energy of others.”
This excerpt is from the article Am I an Empath, a Trauma Survivor or Both? by Kristen Schwartz on elephant journal.
“4 Reasons Why People Become Empaths:
Why do people become empaths? Is it temperament? Genetics? Trauma? Neglectful or supportive parental upbringing? As a psychiatrist and an empath, I’ve seen that the following four main factors (which I expand upon in my book The Empath’s Survival Guide) can contribute to heightening one’s sensitivities.
Reason 1. Temperament. Some babies enter the world with more sensitivity than others—an inborn temperament. You can see it when they come out of the womb. They’re much more responsive to light, smells, touch, movement, temperature, and sound. These infants seem to be empaths from the start.
Reason 2. Genetics. Also, from what I’ve observed with my patients, some forms of sensitivity may be genetically transmitted. Highly sensitive children can come from mothers and fathers with the same inborn traits. Therefore, it is possible that sensitivity can also be genetically transmitted through families.
Reason 3. Trauma. Childhood neglect or abuse can affect your sensitivity levels as an adult. A portion of empaths I’ve treated have experienced early trauma such as emotional or physical abuse, or they were raised by alcoholic, depressed or narcissistic parents. This could potentially wear down the usual healthy defenses that a child with nurturing parents develops. As a result of their upbringing, they typically don’t feel “seen” by their families, and feel invisible in the greater world that doesn’t value sensitivity.
Reason 4. Supportive Parenting. On the other hand, positive parenting can help sensitive children develop and honor their gifts. Parents are powerful role models for all children, especially sensitive ones.
In all cases, however, we empaths haven’t learned to defend against stress in the same way as others do. We’re different in that respect. A noxious stimulus, such as an angry person, crowds, noise, or bright light can agitate us since our threshold for sensory overload is extremely low.”
This excerpt is from the article 4 Reasons Why People Become Empaths: From Trauma to Genetics by Dr. Judith Orloff.
I am curious about your experiences reading about being an empath and trauma response. What “poked” you the most? What shadow work is next for you?
Empath or Trauma Response, or Both?
Reiki is an excellent source of childhood trauma healing.
Other posts you may enjoy:
Stop Trying To Fix Me – I Am Not Broken
Blindness – A Spiritual Teaching in Seeing
The Art of Knowing is Knowing What to Ignore
Spiritual Training on Humility – The Janitor Part I
This Sculpture Shows the Inner Child In Us – Love
Michael Swerdloff
Providence Holistic Counselor, Coach and Reiki
bob carmody
December 3, 2023 (8:17 pm)
pretty generic, not much fact or solutions offered?
Michael
December 3, 2023 (11:25 pm)
Hi Bob, Thanks for commenting. I did not offer any solutions because not every person, and situation are the same. People need to make their own choices on what form of treatment they want as a means for healing trauma.
Ann
April 3, 2024 (8:52 pm)
Very well written Michael, thank you! I had childhood trauma and I’ve always had absorbed energy around me, sometimes it’s very overwhelming. I also use nature for charging my energy. As I’m reading this, you make me feel like we’re having a conversation and that you’re listening to me. It’s enough, no need solution. I understand that I have to make my own. Thanks again